What do we do when the offering count does not match the deposit?
A small difference is common, and it is usually findable. Work through it in order and write down what you find.
Short answer: Do not fix it alone and do not adjust numbers quietly. Compare the signed count sheet with the deposit slip and the bank record, check the usual causes below, write the difference down, and tell the finance chair or the board. Ask your adviser if you are unsure how to record it.
This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.
The steps
Write down the difference first
Subtract the smaller number from the larger and note which is which. For example: count sheet $1,052.00, bank deposit $1,042.00, difference $10.00 less at the bank.
Find the three documents
You need the signed count sheet, the deposit slip that went to the bank, and the line on the bank statement or online banking record. Put them side by side.
Check the deposit slip against the count sheet
Does the slip show the same cash total and the same number of checks? A slip filled in by hand is a common place for a copying error or swapped digits, such as 412 written as 421.
Check the checks one by one
Add up the checks on the sheet, then add up the checks listed on the slip. A missing check, or one counted twice, shows up here.
Ask whether the bank recounted
Banks sometimes correct a deposit if the cash or the addition on the slip differs from what they find. The bank may have posted an adjustment, so look for a separate line or a notice.
Look for timing
A deposit made late on one day may post on the next business day. Check whether the money has simply been recorded on a different date.
Check for items outside the count
A gift handed to the treasurer, a late envelope, or a check that came in the mail may have been added to the deposit without being on that Sunday’s sheet.
Write the answer on a note
State the difference, the cause if you found one, who found it, and the date. File it with the count sheet.
Tell a second person
Report the difference to the finance chair or another board member, whether you solved it or not. A second pair of eyes protects you.
If you cannot find the cause
Write the unexplained difference down and keep it visible. Do not round it away and do not add your own money to cover it. Many churches set a small written amount above which the board must be told. How an unresolved amount is recorded is a bookkeeping question, so ask your adviser if you are unsure.
Prevent the next one
- Photograph or copy the deposit slip before it leaves the building.
- Have the second counter check the slip against the sheet before sealing.
- Keep sheet, slip and bank record together in one folder for each month.
The routine in how to count the Sunday offering is built to avoid most of these.
A worked example (illustration, not real data)
The count sheet shows $1,052.00. The bank statement shows $1,042.00. The treasurer lays out the sheet and the slip. The slip lists cash of $402.00, while the sheet shows $412.00. The counters had found a $10 bill stuck to another note, and the person filling in the slip used the first count. The bank deposited what was on the slip. The treasurer writes a note, both counters initial it, and the finance chair is told. The money is not missing; the slip was wrong.
Questions people ask
Is a small difference a sign that something is wrong?
Not usually. Hand-written slips, a bill stuck to another, or a bank adjustment explain most small differences. What matters is that it is found, written down and reported.
Should we change the count sheet after it was signed?
No. Leave the signed sheet as it was and write a separate note that explains the difference. Changing a signed figure removes the point of signing.
When should we involve the board?
Many churches tell the board about any difference that is not explained within a few days, and set a written amount above which the board is always told. Agree that amount with your board.
Free printable
Open the free offering count sheet, ready to print on US Letter paper. No email needed.