What should a board ask the treasurer each month?
Good questions protect the organization and support the treasurer. Ask them every month, in the same way, so they feel routine and not personal.
Short answer: Ask for the bank balance and whether the account has been reconciled, what came in and went out against the budget, whether anything is unusual, whether bills and filings are on time, and what decisions the board needs to make. Ten questions are below.
This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.
The steps
What is the bank balance, and has the statement been reconciled?
A good answer gives the balance, the date of the statement and who reviewed the reconciliation.
How did income compare with what we expected?
A good answer names the main income lines and explains differences in a sentence.
How did spending compare with the budget?
A good answer points out lines that are close to their limit before they are overspent.
Is any money restricted or set aside, and is it still there?
A good answer shows each fund's balance, and that the funds add up to the bank. See restricted gifts and designated funds.
Were all deposits made on time and did they match the counts?
A good answer says yes, or explains a difference and how it was resolved.
Were all payments approved and supported by a receipt?
A good answer says how approvals work and mentions any exceptions.
Is anything unusual?
A good answer is open. It is fine if the answer is “no”. It is not fine if the treasurer is unwilling to discuss.
What bills, filings or renewals are coming up?
A good answer lists the next two or three months, and says which items depend on law and have been referred to the adviser.
Who else has looked at the records?
A good answer names a second person who reviews the bank statement. If no one does, the board decides who should.
What do you need from us?
A good answer is a short list of decisions, and perhaps a request for help or a break.
How to ask
Ask in a friendly, regular way. The same questions each month turn into a habit, and the treasurer can prepare. Avoid asking in a way that sounds like doubt about the person. Thank the treasurer. A volunteer who feels supported stays in the job, and a board that asks good questions makes the job easier.
What a board should not ask for
Individual giving records and personal details are private. The board needs totals and trends. Detailed records are for the few people who need them for their roles.
Once a year
Once a year, add three more: Who can sign? Have two members done their simple annual review? What are the retention rules our adviser gave us? Related: what to put in a monthly report.
Make it a standing item
Put the ten questions on the agenda as a short standing item, with the treasurer's report. Keep the answers brief and the tone friendly. Over a year the board builds a clear picture, and the treasurer builds confidence that the records are in good order. If a question cannot be answered, it goes on the list for next month. Share the questions with the treasurer in advance, so nothing comes as a surprise, and so the answers can be prepared with the documents at hand. The aim is shared understanding, not an examination, and a treasurer who knows what will be asked can bring exactly what the board needs.
Questions people ask
Should the whole board see the statements?
At least one officer who does not write checks should review them each month. The board decides how much more.
What if the answer to a question is unclear?
Ask for the document and a short follow-up at the next meeting. Unclear is not wrong, but it should not stay unclear.
What if the treasurer does not want to answer?
Stay calm, write down the question, and ask the chair to follow your own process. See warning signs and what to do calmly.
Free printable
Open the free monthly board questions for the treasurer, ready to print on US Letter paper. No email needed.