VThe Vera Standard

How can two members do a simple annual financial review?

Once a year, two people who did not keep the books look through them. It is a friendly check that the records make sense. It is not an audit.

Short answer: Two members who are not the treasurer and not related to the treasurer compare bank statements with the records, look at a sample of payments and receipts, and write a short note of what they checked and found. It is not an audit and does not give assurance the way an audit does. Ask your adviser if you need one.

This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.

The steps

  1. Say plainly what it is

    A review by two members is not an audit. An audit is done by a qualified professional under set standards. This is a simple check by volunteers. Tell the members so, and write it at the top of the report.

  2. Check your rules

    Your bylaws may already describe a review or an audit. If a funder or the law asks for an audit, ask your adviser, because this page does not replace it.

  3. Choose the reviewers

    Pick two members who are not the treasurer, not signers on the account and not related to the treasurer. Choose people the board trusts and who can read a bank statement.

  4. Agree the period and the scope

    Usually the last financial year. Write down what they will check, and give them the records at least two weeks before the report is due.

  5. Give them access

    Records, not logins. Provide bank statements for the year, the books, the count sheets, deposits, bills, receipts, minutes and the budget.

  6. Compare statements with the records

    For each month, check that the opening and closing balances agree with the bank statements and that a reconciliation exists.

  7. Trace a sample of money in

    Pick several deposits across the year and follow each one: count sheet, deposit slip, bank statement, record.

  8. Trace a sample of money out

    Pick several payments, including the largest. Check each has a receipt, an approval and a second signature where your rules require one.

  9. Check the approvals

    Compare spending with the budget and the minutes. Note any payment that has no clear approval.

  10. Check the bank list

    Compare the list of signers and online users with the bank's own list.

  11. Write a short note

    One page: what they looked at, what they found, and any suggestions. Both sign and date. The treasurer can reply.

  12. Present and file

    The reviewers give the note to the board. File it with the year's records.

What the note might say

“We are two members who looked at the records for the year. This is not an audit. We compared all twelve bank statements with the records, followed eight deposits and ten payments from start to finish, and checked the list of signers. We found every item we checked supported by a document. We suggest the board adds a second signature rule for payments over a set amount.” (Example wording, not a real report.)

Be kind

The review is a normal part of the year, not a sign of suspicion. Tell the treasurer early, thank them afterward, and change reviewers every year or two so no one becomes a permanent examiner.

When you need more

If a reviewer finds something they do not understand, they write it down as a question rather than a conclusion, and the board takes it up with the treasurer and, if needed, your adviser.

A short checklist for the reviewers

Keep the list with the note, so next year's reviewers can repeat it.

Questions people ask

Is this the same as an audit?

No. An audit is a professional examination under set standards. This is a volunteer check, and it does not give the same assurance.

Who should not be a reviewer?

The treasurer, anyone who signs on the account, and anyone related to them.

How long does it take?

Often a few evenings for a small organization, if the records are tidy.

Free printable

Open the free annual two-member financial review checklist, ready to print on US Letter paper. No email needed.

Related guides