VThe Vera Standard

What should a board do, calmly, when it suspects a trusted treasurer or bookkeeper?

This is hard because the person is trusted, often for many years. The aim is to find facts, treat everyone fairly, and follow a process, not to decide guilt.

Short answer: Write down what you have seen, tell the board chair or the next officer in your rules, keep it confidential, preserve the records, have someone not involved review them, and ask your adviser what to do next. Do not accuse anyone, confront anyone alone or change records.

This is not tax, legal or accounting advice. It describes common practice. Where a rule depends on law, ask your adviser, and follow your own organization’s rules and your bank’s requirements.

The steps

  1. Pause and breathe

    A worry is not proof. Most irregularities are mistakes, and good people are sometimes careless. Begin by assuming a mistake until facts say otherwise.

  2. Write down facts, not conclusions

    Record dates, amounts, documents and what you saw or were told. Do not write opinions about the person.

  3. Do not confront the person alone

    Do not question them yourself and do not discuss your worry with others. A private word with the chair or another officer is the first step.

  4. Tell the right person

    Tell the board chair, or if the chair is involved, the next officer your bylaws name. Keep the group small and the matter private.

  5. Check your own rules

    Look at your bylaws or policies for what to do. If there is no process, the board decides together, with notes.

  6. Preserve the records

    Keep originals as they are. Do not mark, correct, move or discard anything. Make copies to work from. Keep access logs if you have them.

  7. Ask someone not involved to review

    Ask a member who is not a signer, not related and not close to the person to look at the bank statements, count sheets and deposits for the period, and to write down questions.

  8. Ask your adviser early

    Ask your adviser, and your insurer or denomination office if you have one, what steps to take and whether anyone outside the organization must be told. Follow their guidance.

  9. Treat everyone fairly

    The person is treated with respect and as innocent until facts say otherwise. Give them a chance to explain, at the right time and in the way your adviser suggests.

  10. Protect the money going forward

    Whatever the cause, tighten the routine: a second signature, a monthly review by someone else, prompt deposits. Do it for everyone, not just one person.

  11. Keep a written record of what the board did

    Minutes should show who was told, what was decided and when. Keep them confidential.

What to say, and not say

Helpful: “We would like to check a few figures together; could you help us find these documents?” Not helpful: “We think you have taken money.” Keep words neutral and let facts and your adviser guide next steps. Do not discuss the matter in the congregation, a group chat or on social media.

Looking after the person and the group

Whatever the outcome, a long-trusted volunteer and the whole community are affected. Be kind, keep it confidential, and consider asking your pastor, chair or office for support. A fair process protects the organization whether or not a problem is found.

What this page does not do

We do not give legal advice, and we cannot say what you must report or to whom. Those answers depend on law and on your own rules. Ask your adviser before you act. See also warning signs that money is going missing.

Questions people ask

What should finance members do when they suspect a trusted, long-serving bookkeeper?

Write down the facts, tell the chair privately, keep the records as they are, have someone not involved review them, and ask your adviser what to do. Do not accuse or confront.

Should we tell the congregation?

Not at this stage. Keep the matter confidential and follow your adviser's guidance.

What if the chair is the person we are worried about?

Go to the next officer your rules name, and ask your adviser or your denomination office how to proceed.

Related guides